Tuesday, November 14, 2006

Reply to a mail we received recently

Dear friends,
We at Lok Satta Party believe in replying to each and every mail we receive.We are posting below a mail sent to us by one Mr.Kiran Kumar Reddy. Mr.Jayaprakash Narayan's reply follows.

We hope Mr.Kiran Kumar will not mind us making public his mail. Due to a technical problem, we unfortunately seem to have lost his email Id. Since we have no other way of contacting him,we are posting the reply here on the blog. We hope you see this Mr.Kiran and we apologise for the inconvenience!




Dear Jai prakash Narayan,

I wanted to talk to you about the grave problem of hunger and poverty in the country, I happened to see this news over TV and online.

http://www.ibnlive.com/news/13-boom-for-mkts-doom-for-poor/25093-3.html

[Patna: It’s a shocking tale of two Indias, the irony of which is clearly indicative of the stark socio-economic disparity.
While the country’s business entrepreneurs raised a toast to BSE benchmark Sensex breaching the 13,000 mark on Monday, thousands of miles away in Bihar, a man committed suicide after not having eaten for 13 days.
While stock markets' upward journey from 11K to 13K was marked with nationwide jubilation, this man's agony of starvation for 13 days was lost in anonymity.
Found hanging from the roof of a local passenger train in Patna, all proof that the man left behind of his identity was a suicide note that read: “I don't belong to this world. I am helpless.”
“His body was found tied to a small rack near the berth. He was in a standing position and had apparently hung himself,” says DIG, Railways, Ajay Verma.
In his suicide note, the man - yet to be identified - hasn’t blamed anyone.
All he has repeatedly insisted is that it was his poverty that drove him to starvation, which made him helpless enough to put an end to his life.
“The suicide note says he had not eaten for last 12 days and was only surviving on water. He has also written that no one really cared for him or asked him where he had come from. We’ll get to know more about his death after the post-mortem,” says Verma.
Having lost his battle with hunger after putting up a brave front almost 15 days, this man is perhaps India’s most touching face of hunger and poverty.
But will his thought-provoking suicide note be of any relevance for the powers that be, or will his desperation be lost in the loud celebrations of an India galloping towards the goal of a global superpower?]

My heart is breaking seeing this, where are we going as a society and country, this is not what we want to leave back for the future generations. I don’t think reading these kind of news or hearing this any Indian would be proud that we are doing excellent as a nation.

I feel we have no time and we should work as a movement in this and bring civil society as a part of this movement and make sure no one dies with hunger in this country, I don’t think any company in India or any middle class person or any educated person would have a problem in contributing for this.

The point is who makes them aware of the realities of this country, we should, and we should provide them a medium to contribute back to society especially with regard to aged and helpless people and also the kids on the streets.

Everyone feels sad and hurt hearing all this or reading these, but what can they do other than try and forget if not they cannot go about their daily lives. But I strongly feel we should have system in place where every citizen gets an opportunity to contribute to the hungry and needy in whichever way they can instead of just feeling a moment of un happiness/helplessness and then going about their routine. We should try and build a social security for aged and children of this country unless we take care of the basic needs of our aged and future generation, otherwise we cannot claim to be a great nation.

I think we should find a solution to make people AWARE AND AWAKEN them to this sad state of our country. We should encourage people to participate in these causes which help poor old and children.

There should be minimum 10 old aged home and child care centers in every district and anyone above 50 and below 15 should be given food and medicine and everything to live happily
These centers should be run by retired army with the help of prisoner in open jails or members of society who are interested in helping society.
These centers should be run by the local community without any political or governmental influence only the land and funds should be provided by government.
We should encourage companies contribute for these causes, the ones who contribute should be given privilege like a STAR status or something so that people are keen to go to these shops, so that when they buy something here or eat something here a little goes to the poor.
We should involve the great corporate world of India specially IT, Telecom, Banking and others to contribute to this cause which needs urgent attention, i.e. feed the poor.

I know a contrary argument is that we are going make people complacent but see even in a family set up would we not give care and support to a member who doesn’t work or needs us? The same way we should as a country take care of all its citizens. The argument of providing employment, education etc is fine but there is an urgent need to provide the needy with the most basic of human requirement, which is food - food for the old and children of the country no matter what.

I want to tell you Dr.JP that these are the main reasons that is making me come and join a movement such as the one you have started.

I think we should find a solution to make people awake of this sad state of country. Everyone sees the roads, airports, hotels, shopping malls and think we are progressing, actually we are building a society on the dead bodies of the poor people, they have equal right on this country and its resources and its no utility to them if our country is fast progressing because our progress is in fact taking away from them their most basic requirement, which is food.

I feel so sad and heart broken when I am writing to you, I don’t know how I could have helped the who man died of hunger and I think I don’t want his sacrifice to go waste. As a mark or respect to him I want to initiate this project of old age home and home for kids through our loksatta. I want to go through what he went through, even in a small way, so I skipped lunch, break fast but I feel its not enough.


Yours truly,
Kiran kumar reddy


Reply:

Dear Kiran,
Thank you for the email.Like you, I am moved by the incident.Your passion and conviction are inspiring.I agree that we must also incorporate a program of minimum social security for all to ensure that the indigent and underclass can at least survive with some dignity.

While it is not easy,we, as a country can accomplish that.Let us be in touch to pursue the subject.

Warm regards

Jayaprakash Narayan

6 comments:

  1. Here is the link for Sneha TV Discussions Forum regarding loksatta

    http://www.snehatvonline.com/discussions/viewtopic.php?t=14

    ReplyDelete
  2. Let us start and help from bottom

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear JP,
    Kiran's narration of the state of the nation is really moving. I want to do some thing similar to what Kiran is thinking of. A project to build a old age home and Orphanage to start with. I am in US and I have a network of friends who can support me in this endeavor. I am belonged to a small village in Mahaboob Nagar Dist. I want to start this project in my Village. I want to start this through Lok Satta Party as I am a strong foloower of Lok Satta and admirer of you. Please give me some insight how I can include Lok Satta in this endeavor or how I can associate Lok Satta name to this noble cause

    Venkat

    ReplyDelete
  4. AnonymousJune 17, 2007

    Dear Mr.Jaya prakash Narayan

    First of all my sincere salute to you for your commitment towards nation.I desperately want to join in Lok satta party.I did my B.Tech in 2005. I am 21 yrs old. I seriously want to do service to poor and nation to my best. I personally want to meet you also. Right now am working in chennai in an IT company.

    Hence i request you to give me a chance to meet you.

    Sir kindly reply me and let me the partner of your esteemed vision.

    yours sincerely,
    Sai kiran.K

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dear Mr.Jaya prakash Narayan

    Sir i believe in actions rather than words.You say many things on T.V it is great to hear those things which you say in your speeches.But how can a common man get to know about LokPal bill.Can a farmer in the village will get to know your speeches or else the daily wage Laborer.You talk about rights of people but the poor man in India don't know where is next step for tomorrow is.My advice is you should concentrate on Health and Education improvement and then talk about rights.Sir,what about the Kolleru Movement which you were a part of.I did my B.Tech in 2006. I am 22 yrs old working in the IT Company in Hyderabad.Sir,I'm admirer of our policy's but I'm a critic for the way in which you implement your policies.

    ReplyDelete
  6. AnonymousJuly 26, 2007

    Politics in India are personality driven. Personality cult has been the single largest contributing factor in degrading the quality of politics in India or much of South Asia and other parts of the world as well, in recent times. Bangladesh and Sri Lanka are good examples. Closer home, political landscape is littered with examples. Gandhi Family, NTR, Chandrababu Naidu, Mayawathi, MGR, Jayalalitha, Karunanidhi, Mulayam, Laloo, Thackeray, Devi Lal et al. The organisations controlled by them are little more than for-profit family enterprises masquerading as political parties. Such parties neither have any democratic structure nor appear to have any regard for it. They do not produce second generation leaders. This is dictatorship by other means. Any public good that comes out of these parties is incidental and a by product of personal ambition. If I have to seek exceptions, erstwhile Janatha party and Congress in the early years of independence, also during the intervening period between Rajiv Gandhi and Sonia Gandhi, at least have gone through a democratic phase, in a relative sense that is. Currently BJP appears to have a greater democratic structure, again in a relative sense, as it seems capable of producing alternative leaders, one of the visible manifestations of internal democracy. Indeed there are examples of personalities who had the vision and achievement to justify their popularity but they are an exception and products of particular social and historical situations. I am sure I do not have to point out the consequences of personality cult to you -centralising power and quelling dissidence-the latter particularly an attack on democracy. The perversion then sets in.

    The reason for this preamble is to seek to know how democratic Loksatta Party is. Indeed the party constitution document conveys a democratic structure and a commitment to party democracy. Exceptional people seem to be heading the party and highly capable and committed persons working for the party and the Loksatta NGO (I personally met a few). The party may even be functioning in a democratic manner. However, if anyone looks at the websites of the party and the NGO, an altogether different impression is created. More than the party and the NGO, it is the JP brand that appears to be promoted. The websites are littered with JP, letters, articles, speeches, travels, comments, statements analyses. The blogs at both the party level and individual level are by JP. There doesn't appear to be space for anyone else. There is no spokesperson for the party. No party line on anything but JP line. This is at the expense of other functionaries. I am sure there are other capable persons who are doing exceptional work. They contribute equally to the work, research, analysis and campaigns. It might be a better idea to highlight the work and insights of other important functionaries as well. Comments and experiences of other senior party functionaries will be invaluable. This of course can be within the party and NGO guidelines. This has many advantages. Foremost among them is it conveys to the world that there is more to party and the NGO than just JP. It will portray these as institutions in the making than as vehicles for personal advancement and promotion of individual agenda. It enhances legitimacy.

    We know that feudalistic mentality and the culture of deferring to the leaders and seniors breeds unquestioning loyalty and an uncritical attitude. Moving away from this and encouraging individual creativity and discussion will lead to a healthy party with a moral authority. This is not a comment upon your personal capabilities, charisma or your commitment. Indeed these are your outstanding characteristics. Moreover, as a founding member of the party and current leader, certain privileges accrue to you. The party needs your vision, direction and leadership. However, for people interested in this party, it is useful to know whether the party practices what it preaches and claims to stand for. What is its long term vision and strategy in terms of party organisation, structure and future?

    I am aware this is direct, hard hitting and controversial and may not see the light o the day. But it is test.

    ReplyDelete